Every second week there is one topic that has something to do with book-blogging that you can discuss on your blog.
This week's topic is: Comments. The holy grail of blogging success! What type of posts do you leave comments on? How do you try to encourage more comments on your blog? Do you respond to people who leave comments on your posts? How do you handle negative/spam comments? Do you use captcha?
I love comments. Comments are one of the things I like best about blogging. I get excited every time I see I got a new comment. Especially those thoughtful comments telling me someone likes what I'm doing, or a comment saying someone will read a book because of my review - comments like that make my day. I am so thankful to anyone who has ever left a comment on my blog.
I don't really know how I encourage commenting on my blog, other than just consistently providing quality content. Other than memes (which don't really count, in my opinion, because writing 'great IMM!' and leaving a link to your own IMM post is not a thoughtful comment), the posts that get the most comments are discussion posts. Whenever I do something new, like start a new feature, I get a lot of comments, too. Really, anything unusual gets a lot of comments - not the reviews I write all the time, but something readers haven't seen before. Now, that's not a way to consistently get comments, since you can't start a new feature or write a discussion post every day - we need to write normal reviews and continue older features, too. But that's when I've noticed I get the most comments.
I've also noticed that I get more comments on positive reviews than on negative ones - I guess it's just easier to write 'I loved this one, glad you liked it too!' than to discuss a negative review. That's a little disappointing, honestly, because I think a discussion in the comments would be great - I want to know what other people thought, why someone liked that book when I didn't, anything like that. But that type of discussion doesn't happen often. And it's not something you can influence, either - you can't only write positive reviews because they get more comments. Really, I think it just comes down to consistently providing quality content, and people will comment when they have something to say. I think ending every post with a question is nice, too, and lets people know that comments are definitely welcome.
For the month of May, I've decided to do a Comment Contest - each comment you leave on my blog this month is an entry for a giveaway, in which you can win a May release of you choice. I've seen a huge increase in comments since then, so I'd say that idea works! I don't know how much it'll help in the long term, since I don't know whether I'll be able to afford doing a Comment Contest every month. But for now, I'm loving all the comments!
But even though I love getting comments on my blog, I'm not exactly good at leaving comments on other blogs. I have a few blogs I comment on regularly, but other than that, I don't comment all that much. I read a lot of blog posts, but I just don't comment often. I think I'm more likely to comment on smaller blogs - I feel bad when I see a post with 0 comments and want to leave one, while I think my comment wouldn't really make a difference to someone who already got 20 comments on their review. When there's something I want to say, when I feel like I actually have something to contribute, I do comment - but I feel weird writing something generic like 'Great review! I really want to read this book!' so I usually just don't. It was one of my New Year's resolutions to comment more, and the way it always is with those, right at the beginning of the year, I commented loads, but now I'm back to not commenting much. I really need to work on that.
And as to whether I reply to comments on my posts - of course! Well, I don't respond to every comment, but when someone asks a question or leaves a thoughtful comment I'd like to add something to, always. I think responding to comments, and thereby interacting with the people who read you're blog, is very important, since building a blog community is basically the ultimate goal.
Now, about whether I use Captcha... NO! I hate Captcha. I'm sorry, but if your blog has Captcha, I probably won't bother commenting. The new Blogger Captcha is so hard to read! And honestly, I don't really see the point. I've never used Captcha, and I've gotten, like, two spam comments in my one and a half years of blogging, which I've just deleted. If you're worried about spam - which I'm not, considering I get basically none - turn on comment moderation, but stay away from Captcha!
And about negative comments - I think you have to distinguish between comments that respectfully disagree and hateful comments. Comments that respectfully disagree are great - not everyone is going to agree with my opinion, and that's fine. I love when a discussion starts in the comments, as long as everyone keeps it respectful. Hateful comments are different, though. I've gotten only one, as far as I can remember, but that one was pretty hurtful. It was on a negative review of mine and insulted me for not getting what the book was really about it, using language I don't want to repeat here. I felt hurt for about a day and doubted myself a little, but then I just deleted the comment - if you want to discuss a book with me, that's fine, but don't insult me for my opinion. I won't have negativity or language like that on my blog, so I feel I deleting the comment was the right thing to do. I'm grateful I haven't gotten much negative response - I hear that April from Good Books and Good Wine gets hate mail, like, every day, which is crazy. But I guess there are always going to be hateful people out there. I just try to focus on the positve!
So that's what I think of comments - I love every single comment I get, but I myself need to work on commenting more. What are your thoughts on blog comments?